oh so many!
iv'e seen all yours except house.
i really REALLY recommened veronica mars. It is my favourite show of all time. Its about a teenage girl whos friend got murdered (in season 1) and shes kind of a detective. sounds cheesy, but its so amazing. look it up on google!
if not, try one of these (in order of awesomeness)
Buffy the vampire slayer( ok when someone first suggested this i turned up my nose. 'vampire slayer? sounds so supernatural and i just dont like that." then i gave it a try and its brilliant.
roswell(most underrated show ever made, about three ailen kids and they fall in love with humans etc etc well its great),
LOST(about a plane crash and its survivors, it gets a bit silly at times though, still great),
degrassi junior high (an oldie but a goodie made in 1980s basically a show about teenagers and their life),
and smallville, which is about superman growing up basically. You don't seem to be into that stuff, but i reckon they're as good as greys anatomy, desperate housewives etc because they still all have romance and excitment just told in a more interesting way.
i hope you take my advice - not all supernatural shows are bad. they're actually some of the best.
or if you want two hot guys check out supernatural - about two brothers who fight ghosts and demons and its really cool.
but seriously - i reccomend veronica mars, you wont regret it.