Question:
Why has reading become such a sin in today's society?
2012-10-09 13:40:35 UTC
I'm 16 and I love to read, I've read countless books, from the Bible to "The god delusion".... And my cousin always makes fun of me because I like to read so much, and he so stupid, like he really is, his grammar sucks and he's barely passing school, so why is today's society so against reading now adays.
Eight answers:
Amol
2012-10-09 13:48:12 UTC
Just because one person makes fun of you dosent make it a generalized sin in the society...

Dont think too much..tehre are much better people in teh world to think of...

as far as your cousin is concerned, I think he's just pulling your leg just for the heck of it...dont let it get on to you....



Have fun
n8boi02
2012-10-09 23:24:39 UTC
Well I don't see reading as a sin I mean I'm 28 and I'm actually proud to admit that I've read every Harry Potter book up until the order of the phoenix. And I still like to read Nintendo Power (too bad it'll gone at the end of the year). And I even like to look up information on Wikipedia as well as my favorite websites. So if you ask me I say calling reading a sin (even in today's society) is more of a matter of opinion to each his own I say.
Jesere
2012-10-09 20:43:45 UTC
you are the one who is stupid

for making such aerroneousus comment

Society is not against reading.



The report, “Reading on the Rise: A New Chapter in American Literacy,” being released Monday, is based on data from “The Survey of Public Participation in the Arts” conducted by the United States Census Bureau in 2008. Among its chief findings is that for the first time since 1982, when the bureau began collecting such data, the proportion of adults 18 and older who said they had read at least one novel, short story, poem or play in the previous 12 months has risen.



The news comes as the publishing industry struggles with declining sales amid a generally difficult economy.



Nevertheless the proportion of overall literary reading increased among virtually all age groups, ethnic and demographic categories since 2002. It increased most dramatically among 18-to-24-year-olds, who had previously shown the most significant declines.
?
2012-10-09 20:46:54 UTC
I don't know, I mean there are an awful lot of eReaders these days so I don't think reading is looked down upon
Reuben ✡
2012-10-09 22:13:45 UTC
It's not just reading, but the greater expansion of a stereotype, and it's not just in today's society, there is a long history in which the educated or otherwise intellectually knowledgeable have been vilified, in both American society and the wider world. It's deeper than words such as 'nerd' and 'geek' being used as slurs in the playground.



Anti-intellectualism in the United States predates its national identity itself, and there is a long history within its education system in which there is little interest in developing children's minds, or for the pride of learning; but rather views its children as abiding citizens of a future 'democracy' to be trained. The 'No Child Left Behind Act' of 2001 was the final nail in the coffin following many decades of dumbing down the system, in which the teaching of critical thinking for today's children has been stolen from their innocent minds, and replaced with standardized drilling of information into their minds, it's now memorization memorization memorization.



Intellectuals became an oddity with the rise of McCarthyism, once highly respected they became targets of suspicion for Communist activities (itself becoming a slur for all Communist affiliations). The American public turned against intellectuals, distrusting them and turning them into scapegoats for income tax and the attack on Pearl Harbor. As Arthur Meier Schlesinger Jr stated at the time, 'anti-intellectualism is the antisemitism of the businessman'. With McCarthyism, banks, corporations, government became suspicious of Communist infiltrators. Education no longer counted for much in the workplace, nor did independent thinking. The new order was to become sheep, to stay in line and blend in with the general populace. President Eisenhower spread that distaste of intellects, speaking at a Republican meeting in Los Angeles in 1954 he stated; '... By the way, I heard a definition for an intellectual that I thought was very interesting, a man who takes more words than are necessary to tell more than he knows'.



With the passing of McCarthyism, the trend continued in society and of course remains today watered down in the beginning words I mentioned used as slurs. To be an intellect following McCarthyism, meant to be part of a privileged highly educated elite. Of course, to be an elite makes you open to not just anti-intellectualist attack, but the diatribe of the anti-elitists. It puts you out of touch with the Average Joe and the Plain Jane and upsets the social class, regardless of social background. The education system of the United States of America is failing drastically in today's society, as a result the United States has one of the worst education systems in the post-industrialized world and heavily relies on the foreign born coming to the United States to take up PhD's, with 55% of all PhD engineering graduates and 80% of all chemical & material engineering graduates being foreign born.



Unfortunately, there is a collective narcissism in society, and those outside our immediate social groups as a result are often perceived as strange or weird. This collective narcissism prevails in the school yard. Unfortunately the stereotype of the educated is oft linked with social isolation. This stereotype is enforced on anyone that doesn't meet the standardized needs to be one of the Average Joes.



The above however is part of a wider issue within society and politics itself. The United States doesn't do enough both socially and politically to promote education and educated intellectual pursuits such as reading. Instead the government as aforementioned, ruined the education system for memorization.



It is deeply regrettable that society has a deeper love and respect for the likes of the Hilton's and the Kardashians amongst us, rather than the Higgs, Hawking's, Hansen's or Dawkings. Arguably most children now dream of becoming celebutante's and leading jet set lifestyles with little or no work, than becoming a doctor, teacher, scientist, or the plethora of professions that contribute greatly to society.
Awesome
2012-10-09 20:58:23 UTC
Facebook & Twitter also, Tumblr
2012-10-09 20:43:44 UTC
Because now there are cell phones, internet and all that so...
Kyle
2012-10-09 20:48:38 UTC
CRAP, I just did it again..

Damn, you just did it too.



Is it a sin if we cannot control ourselves to do it?


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...