Question:
Do you REALLY believe that geniuses have NO common sense?
anonymous
2007-10-23 08:40:31 UTC
Do you REALLY believe that geniuses have NO common sense?
28 answers:
Weatherman
2007-10-23 08:44:27 UTC
The ones I have met definately fit into that category
ConcernedCitizen
2007-10-23 15:48:14 UTC
No, I think that's a myth started by less intelligent people who want to find fault with geniuses in order to feel better about themselves. As Red_F said above, there's little or no correlation between intelligence and common sense. There are geniuses with a lot of common sense and some with very little, just like the rest of the population.
anonymous
2007-10-23 15:48:11 UTC
Not all have common sense just like the general population.



Common sense has little to do with intelligence, it is how you are raised. I have known people that were dumb as a brick but had great common sense and I have also known people that were amazingly intelligent that were lost with the simple things.



It's about learning from life experiences more than anything else. Some people just lead sheltered lives and have no common sense.
uncle_buck71
2007-10-23 15:46:22 UTC
No i think that some geniuses focus on some things so much that the common things seem to escape them. So it appears that they do not have common sense but actually the common things hold no intrest.
Khana S
2007-10-24 04:34:14 UTC
**grins sheepishly**



I was sent to a psychologist for my learning difficulties in school, and he discovered at that point that I'm academically a genius.



Not only do I lack common sense, but I lack virtually every other mental sense out there. I've got conceptual understanding. It's like one of those video games where you dish out a set number of points to different attributes.



I gave every last point to conceptual understanding. No social sense, common sense, memorization, visualization, nadda. But I do damn well in chemistry class.



**smiles** On a more serious note, I'm very sensible in very specific circumstances. Virtually all of my interactions with people, things, books, etc, are purely analytical, logical... all mental. Thus, things like college classrooms (as opposed to the more social-based elementary school) I excell in, whereas social situations I fail. There are simply too many variables to understand in a timely fashion. I'm not permitted even 30 seconds to process the possible meanings of a person's statement. In order to be social, my response needs to be instantaneous. Yet, for any given statement, coupled with different body reactions, it could mean hundreds of things. I try to analyze each possibility to see what is the most probable... but as you can imagine, I either A take too long and look like an idiot, B hastily go with my first impression (which is literally random) and 90% of the time be wrong, or C devote 100% of my mental ability to analyzing their reactions as quickly as possible. Which means, I'm barely decent at judging them, but then stammer, say bizarre things, and just sound idiotic.



In short? People think in different ways, some of which cannot adapt to "normal" human behaviour.
anonymous
2007-10-23 16:28:13 UTC
I believe that.. to a degree.. my fiance' is really book smart but damn.. she is a sandwhich short of a full picknic baskett on the common sense side... I mean I gave her mony for 2 weeks of food and she came back with 2 paks of chicken about 3 cans of veggies.. and 2 damn starbuck mugs 12 dollars a piece and chinese food and fast food.. out of the $100 I gave her she spent $62.00 pocketed the rest.. and since I never go in the kitchen I would have never known .. but that day I was in there for something and I noticed and asked her about it.. shes dumb as hell..
Hot Head
2007-10-23 15:49:03 UTC
Most geniuses have no common sense because they're taking in with their genius.
anonymous
2007-10-23 15:45:34 UTC
Nope. I'm a genius (sounds pretentious, I know) and I have plenty of common sense.

But let's define common sense, shall we? Is it really so common? Do more people possess it than not?

I think that when most people are discussing this, they're addressing strictly "Social Faux Pas" Yeah, it's true that geniuses tend to be less sociable, and more inclined to independent seeking and inquiry. Sharing their insights sporadically with those close to them, and are always slight eccentric and 'abnormal.' But normal is not something people should aspire to be. Being normal means that you just accept things as they are, and don't try to change them. That's the standard definition of normal. A typical, ordinary citizen who doesn't rock the boat.

So no, we have plenty of sense, none of which is common, and we enjoy the world slightly differently than most, and we try to change what we observe as inherently flawed or unrealistic.
anonymous
2007-10-23 15:44:35 UTC
I don't think that is true. I'm a genius and I believe I have lots of common sense. I slept with 15 guys last month and now I'm pregnant. I'm not sure who the father is and I'm not sure why none of these guys have asked to marry me yet.
anonymous
2007-10-23 18:08:22 UTC
I don't know perhaps it is just a misnomer, then again if they're truly genius, they may be in such a state, as if they were in another dimension, that yes they are or could be out of touch with the environment around them perhaps not common sense, perhaps bordering insanity.
confuscious
2007-10-23 15:55:39 UTC
That really depends on the person. There are also some people with alot of common sense that are illiterate and aren't very book smart period. So, it works both ways. Btw, you rock!!
Kamunyak
2007-10-23 15:44:43 UTC
Well... maybe not absolutely no common sense, but it seems to be true that people who are highly intelligent seem to get wrapped up in there own thought process and there own world that they seem to forget about the rest of it.
anonymous
2007-10-23 15:45:50 UTC
i believe they have lots of common sense, just yesterday I took a shower while on the phone so i could be more productive. that made a lot of sense!
Butter
2007-10-23 16:21:48 UTC
That's because they don't.

My older sister is an idiot savant. She's so......smart has her Masters degree in international buisness from USC and she has traveld the world knows 5 languages but when it comes down to something simple like changing a diaper or making a grilled cheese she panics because she don't know squat!!!

No common sense.
anonymous
2007-10-23 15:45:36 UTC
Not necessarily. Sometimes they are just sharper in other areas. I am a genius and I have a little common sense. LOL.
?
2007-10-23 15:46:15 UTC
A friend of mine has an IQ that of a genius. Yet it takes him 10 mins to get chips and a soda at 7-11, and almost 30 mins to get dressed.



drives me nuts.
ALASPADA
2007-10-23 16:19:26 UTC
No because I have two female friends who have Mensa level IQs and they both lead very fine and productive lives and many times give me the best advice on life situations.
anonymous
2007-10-23 15:43:59 UTC
everyone has common sense, unintelligent people just want to make out they have more of it than intelligent people, so they can at least feel superior to them in *one* resepect. But I doubt it's really true.
~Cheta K.~
2007-10-23 15:43:58 UTC
i'm not sure about common sense but some of them have a hard time loosening up and don't take to well to certain jokes because they are always serious and so techincal and precise about everything
Leaf on the Wind
2007-10-23 15:43:30 UTC
Yes.
Rick R , Super Duper Samurai 侍
2007-10-23 15:42:32 UTC
I would say yes, but then id be slamming myself.
JOHN
2007-10-23 15:42:32 UTC
no but flightness is common
jeff
2007-10-23 15:44:33 UTC
yes
howmanyidsdoihave
2007-10-23 15:43:29 UTC
dont know, but i do believe that people who use porn actresses as their avators have issues!!
Agent 47™ Inc
2007-10-23 15:44:39 UTC
most people that I do know with high intellegence don't
Snot Me
2007-10-23 15:43:36 UTC
yes i do
shys mama
2007-10-23 15:42:51 UTC
very true
anonymous
2007-10-23 15:49:00 UTC
no D:

Wtf?


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...